Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-20 Thunderworks Games 0 views

Roll Player All-in Bundle vs Cartographers All-in Bundle: Which to Buy

Roll Player All-in Bundle vs Cartographers All-in Bundle: Which to Buy

Compare the two all-in bundles from Thunderworks Games: Roll Player and Cartographers. Learn what each includes, who each suits best, and how to decide based on your play style.

Two all-in bundles, two different games

Thunderworks Games offers two all-in bundles that collect every piece of content released for their flagship titles: Roll Player and Cartographers. Both save money compared to buying each item separately, and both come in a single purchase. But the games themselves are very different, so the right choice depends on what you want to play.

This article compares what each bundle actually contains, who each game suits, and the honest trade-offs you should consider before buying.

What each bundle includes

  • Roll Player - All-in Bundle: Roll Player - All-in Bundle includes: Roll Player base game, Monsters & Minions expansion, Fiends & Familiars expansion (Big Box), Metal Coins, Playmat, Dice Tower, Lenticular Monster Cards, Frogkin Promo Punchboard, Minotaur Promo Punchboard, Lockup Pack, and a 2-Card Promo Pack. This bundle covers the entire Roll Player line in one box. If you want to build fantasy heroes and equip them with dice, this is a complete collection.
    Roll Player - All-in Bundle
    Roll Player - All-in Bundle
  • Cartographers - All-in Bundle: Cartographers - All-in Bundle includes: Cartographers base game, Cartographers Heroes (Collector's Edition), Playmat, Colored Pencils, six Map Packs, and five Mini-Expansions (Skills 1 & 2, Ambush 1 & 2, Champions, Architects). This bundle gives you both the original map-drawing game and its standalone sequel, plus all extra content. It's a one-stop purchase for fans of the series.
    Cartographers - All-in Bundle
    Cartographers - All-in Bundle

How the games play

Roll Player is a dice-drafting game where you build a fantasy hero by rolling and assigning dice to improve stats, skills, and equipment. It's a competitive puzzle for 1–4 players, with a focus on optimizing your character build each round.

Cartographers is a flip-and-write (or roll-and-write) game where you draw map shapes on a grid based on revealed cards. It supports 1–100 players simultaneously, making it a great choice for large groups or solo play. The Heroes expansion adds new map packs and a campaign mode.

Both games are about making smart choices under constraints, but the feel at the table is very different: Roll Player is about dice management and character progression, while Cartographers is about spatial planning and pattern recognition.

Key differences at a glance

  • Player count: Roll Player plays 1–4. Cartographers plays 1–100, so it scales much better for large groups or solo sessions.
  • Game time: No official play times are listed for either. Roll Player tends to run longer per player due to its dice-drafting rounds; Cartographers is generally quicker and more simultaneous.
  • Age range: Neither bundle lists a specific age range in the supplied information. Roll Player involves more reading and dice manipulation, while Cartographers is purely shape-drawing and may suit younger players.
  • Components: Roll Player includes a dice tower, metal coins, and a playmat – tactile extras that enhance the dice experience. Cartographers includes colored pencils and a playmat, plus a Collector's Edition box for storage.

Honest trade-offs to consider

The Roll Player bundle is the better pick if you enjoy dice manipulation, character optimization, and a more involved table presence. Its expansions add meaningful new mechanics, and the included metal coins and dice tower are nice upgrades. However, the game is capped at 4 players, so it won't work for larger gatherings.

The Cartographers bundle is the better choice if you want a game that scales from solo to huge groups, or if you prefer quiet puzzle-solving over dice rolling. The Collector's Edition box is a practical storage solution, and the six map packs give you a lot of variety. But if you don't enjoy drawing shapes or managing a grid, this won't change that.

Neither bundle includes the Cartographers backstory card (now out of print), so don't expect that to be part of the Cartographers purchase.

Making your decision

Ask yourself two questions: How many people will usually play? And do you prefer dice or drawing?

If you typically play with 1–3 others and love dice, go with the Roll Player All-in Bundle. If you want a game for any player count and enjoy map-style puzzles, the Cartographers All-in Bundle is the one. Both offer excellent value compared to buying the components separately.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile